List of models

From Wiki Les Houches 09

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
Current revision (08:14, 2 October 2009) (view source)
 
(27 intermediate revisions not shown.)
Line 1: Line 1:
-
This is a list of models producing boosted W and Z bosons (with x-section estimates), ranked by other objects in the event.
+
This is a list of models producing boosted W and Z bosons (with x-section estimates), ranked by other objects in the event. See also the [[Jet Substructure]] page for discussions of techniques for reconstructing boosted hadronic W/Z/H.
 +
 
 +
An attempt to outline a write-up for this work is at the very bottom.
'''Pairs (WW/WZ/ZZ)''':
'''Pairs (WW/WZ/ZZ)''':
-
*Objects like W' and Z'
+
* Warped/(partially) composite Standard Model (SM): this framework can address both the Planck-weak and flavor hierarchy problems of the SM. For
-
*W,Z from Heavy neutrinos pair production from Z' in the U(1)_B-L model [http://www.http://www.hep.phys.soton.ac.uk/~l.basso/Les_Houches_09_Basso.pdf Basso LH09 talk]
+
a review talk about this framework, see http://indico.cern.ch/getFile.py/access?contribId=5&resId=1&materialId=slides&confId=46139
-
Heavy neutrino pair production: up to ~100fb, decaying in
+
and http://indico.cern.ch/materialDisplay.py?materialId=slides&confId=60488.
 +
 
 +
In the following, W', Z', graviton', t', b' denote Kaluza-Klein (KK) W, Z, graviton, top and bottom in warped extra dimensional picture or composite W,Z, graviton, top and bottom in the dual (via AdS/CFT) 4D picture of partial compositeness of SM. There's also a particle called "radion" (fluctuation of size of extra dimension) which is like Higgs' (i.e., couplings similar to SM Higgs). Very rough cross-sections (they vary a bit depending on details of the model) for the processes are given below:
 +
 
 +
(1). W' (2 TeV) -> WZ, WH: ~O(10) fb each
 +
 
 +
(see reference http://arXiv.org/pdf/0810.1497 for precise cross-sections and other details. The process W' ->  t bbar - giving boosted
 +
t and b - can also give similar reach for W'. Interestingly, the gluon' -> t tbar - with gluon' mass beinig similar to W' - can be a siginificant background to this channel since highly boosted t can fake b: techniques similar to the ones used to identify highly boosted tops
 +
can now be applied to veto the top faking b.)
 +
 
 +
For a CalcHEP implementation of a KK charged state and a KK neutral state see (from Shri):
 +
  http://quark.phy.bnl.gov/~shri/LH09/
 +
The CalcHEP model file KKVLH09_v1.tar.gz can be used to study boosted W, Z and tops resulting from 
 +
W' -> W+ Z , Z' -> W+ W- , W' -> t bbar , Z' -> t tbar ... etc.
 +
An LHA event file is also available at this location if you would prefer to use this instead. (Please see the README file there for more information.)
 +
 
 +
(2). Z' (2 TeV) -> WW, ZH: ~O(10) fb each
 +
 
 +
(see reference http://arXiv.org/pdf/0709.0007 for precise cross-sections and other details. The process Z' -> t tbar also has similar
 +
rate, but it can be swamped by gluon' -> t tbar if the Z' and gluon' have similar mass.)
 +
 
 +
(3) graviton' (2 TeV) -> WW, ZZ, HH: ~O(10) fb each
 +
 
 +
(see references http://arXiv.org/pdf/hep-ph/0701186, http://arXiv.org/pdf/0711.3175 and http://arXiv.org/pdf/0806.3427 for precise cross-sections and other details.)
 +
 
 +
(4). Higgs' -> WW, ZZ, HH
 +
 
 +
(see reference http://arXiv.org/pdf/0705.3844 for more details. Also, see [http://www-pnp.physics.ox.ac.uk/~karagozm/workshops/leshouches09/muge_boosted.ppt Seung+Muge]talk)
 +
 
 +
Model file for CalcHEP implementation of RS radion (with radion mass larger than ~400 GeV) is linked in the following link (from Seung):
 +
http://www-pnp.physics.ox.ac.uk/~karagozm/workshops/leshouches09/radion_model.tgz . As of 24th june 09, these files can be downloaded and used.
 +
 
 +
With this model file, sigma(gg->R->WW) is about 0.1pb at 10 TeV and 0.3pb at 14TeV, for m_radion=500 GeV. This makes radion in various decay channels feasible at LHC.
 +
Corresponding cross section plot for r->WW by Muge is [http://www-pnp.physics.ox.ac.uk/~karagozm/workshops/leshouches09/radion_ww.eps here].
 +
 
 +
(5). t', b' -> t/b + W/Z/H
 +
 
 +
The composite/KK partners of fermions have typically masses similar to W'/Z' and hence are constrained to be ~2 TeV (in turn, based on
 +
masses of W'/Z' required to satisfy precision tests). DIRECT constraints on masses of these fermions can be weaker. In this case, even single
 +
production of these fermionic partners might be very small (pair production is even smaller).
 +
 
 +
However, in certain (well-motivated) models the partners of top, bottom  (in the generalized sense, i.e., including extended symmetries/representations for fermions) can be lighter than W'/Z', possibly ~500 GeV. Hence, production (both pair and single,
 +
perhaps in association with other SM particles) can be significant. The fermionic partners can decay into t/b + W/Z/H, with W/Z
 +
being boosted (even for fermionic partners being ~500 GeV).  For example, for pair production of B' at 500 GeV, production sigma = ~ 1pb @10 TeV.
 +
 +
In addition, some models have "exotic" heavy/composite fermions, i.e., with electric charges 4/3 and 5/3.
 +
 
 +
(see references http://arXiv.org/pdf/hep-ph/0701158 and http://arXiv.org/pdf/0801.1679 for more details. Also, see [http://www-pnp.physics.ox.ac.uk/~karagozm/workshops/leshouches09/muge_boosted.ppt Seung+Muge's talk].)
 +
 
 +
[A few comments are in order:
 +
 
 +
(a) It turns out that W/Z in all channels above are dominantly LONGITUDINAL. All the above decay patterns follow automatically
 +
from overlaps of profiles in extra dimension: light SM fermions are localized near the Planck brane and photon, gluon and transverse W/Z have flat profiles, whereas all KK's, Higgs (including longitudinal W/Z) and top quark are localized near the TeV brane. In the 4D picture, the light fermions are mostly elementary and Higgs and top are mostly composite, whereas photon, gluon and transverse W/Z are sort of in-between.
 +
 
 +
(b) As mentioned above, masses below 2 TeV for W'/Z' are strongly disfavored by lower-energy precision tests, whereas graviton' mass is
 +
expected to be of similar size to W'/Z' and hence is (in turn) also constrained to be above ~2 TeV. Radion mass can vary from
 +
~100 GeV to ~2 TeV.
 +
 
 +
(c) Finally, one can lower the UV brane scale to below Planck scale, of course at the expense of not explaining
 +
the full Planck-weak hierarchy (but still explaining the flavor hierarchy). Such a modified framework - dubbed "little RS": see reference - leads to larger couplings to light fermions than the framework which explains the Planck-weak hierarchy, whereas couplings to top/W/Z/H are reduced. Hence, production cross-section for W'/Z' via q qbar annihilation is enhanced and so are the decays to cleaner channels such as
 +
dileptons.]
 +
 
 +
 
 +
*W,Z from Heavy neutrinos pair production from Z' in the U(1)_B-L model [http://www.hep.phys.soton.ac.uk/~l.basso/Les_Houches_09_Basso.pdf Basso LH09 talk]
 +
Heavy neutrino pair production: up to ~100fb, decaying in (see reference http://arxiv.org/pdf/0812.4313 for more details):
 +
 
- WW+2leptons (up to ~25fb);
- WW+2leptons (up to ~25fb);
 +
- WZ+1leptons + MET (up to ~25fb);
- WZ+1leptons + MET (up to ~25fb);
 +
- ZZ+MET (up to ~6fb);
- ZZ+MET (up to ~6fb);
 +
- WH+1leptons + MET (up to ~25fb);
- WH+1leptons + MET (up to ~25fb);
 +
- ZH+MET (up to ~12fb);
- ZH+MET (up to ~12fb);
 +
- HH+MET (up to ~6fb);
- HH+MET (up to ~6fb);
-
*...
+
 
 +
---
 +
 
 +
'''Outline''':
 +
 
 +
Please put your input here, and sign up where you would volunteer to work. Some usual suspects are already listed.
 +
 
 +
(Note: depending on the details level, we still may have various options: we could turn each section into seperate write-ups or have each KK particle as a seperate write-up)
 +
 
 +
''Summary of warped phenomenology in boosted final states''
 +
 
 +
* Introduction to phenomenology (Kaustubh/Christophe)
 +
 
 +
* List of particles with suggested model parameters from current EWK constraints and yields at the LHC
 +
 
 +
** bosons
 +
 
 +
*** radions (Rogerio/Christophe/Muge/Seung?)
 +
*** KK gravitions (Shri?)
 +
*** KK W/Z (?)
 +
 
 +
** fermions (Muge?/?)
 +
 
 +
* Comments on LHC prospects in various final states (James/Heather/Muge/?)
 +
 
 +
** fully hadronic
 +
** semileptonic
 +
** fully leptonic
 +
 
 +
* Summary (all)

Current revision

This is a list of models producing boosted W and Z bosons (with x-section estimates), ranked by other objects in the event. See also the Jet Substructure page for discussions of techniques for reconstructing boosted hadronic W/Z/H.

An attempt to outline a write-up for this work is at the very bottom.

Pairs (WW/WZ/ZZ):

  • Warped/(partially) composite Standard Model (SM): this framework can address both the Planck-weak and flavor hierarchy problems of the SM. For

a review talk about this framework, see http://indico.cern.ch/getFile.py/access?contribId=5&resId=1&materialId=slides&confId=46139 and http://indico.cern.ch/materialDisplay.py?materialId=slides&confId=60488.

In the following, W', Z', graviton', t', b' denote Kaluza-Klein (KK) W, Z, graviton, top and bottom in warped extra dimensional picture or composite W,Z, graviton, top and bottom in the dual (via AdS/CFT) 4D picture of partial compositeness of SM. There's also a particle called "radion" (fluctuation of size of extra dimension) which is like Higgs' (i.e., couplings similar to SM Higgs). Very rough cross-sections (they vary a bit depending on details of the model) for the processes are given below:

(1). W' (2 TeV) -> WZ, WH: ~O(10) fb each

(see reference http://arXiv.org/pdf/0810.1497 for precise cross-sections and other details. The process W' -> t bbar - giving boosted t and b - can also give similar reach for W'. Interestingly, the gluon' -> t tbar - with gluon' mass beinig similar to W' - can be a siginificant background to this channel since highly boosted t can fake b: techniques similar to the ones used to identify highly boosted tops can now be applied to veto the top faking b.)

For a CalcHEP implementation of a KK charged state and a KK neutral state see (from Shri):

 http://quark.phy.bnl.gov/~shri/LH09/ 

The CalcHEP model file KKVLH09_v1.tar.gz can be used to study boosted W, Z and tops resulting from W' -> W+ Z , Z' -> W+ W- , W' -> t bbar , Z' -> t tbar ... etc. An LHA event file is also available at this location if you would prefer to use this instead. (Please see the README file there for more information.)

(2). Z' (2 TeV) -> WW, ZH: ~O(10) fb each

(see reference http://arXiv.org/pdf/0709.0007 for precise cross-sections and other details. The process Z' -> t tbar also has similar rate, but it can be swamped by gluon' -> t tbar if the Z' and gluon' have similar mass.)

(3) graviton' (2 TeV) -> WW, ZZ, HH: ~O(10) fb each

(see references http://arXiv.org/pdf/hep-ph/0701186, http://arXiv.org/pdf/0711.3175 and http://arXiv.org/pdf/0806.3427 for precise cross-sections and other details.)

(4). Higgs' -> WW, ZZ, HH

(see reference http://arXiv.org/pdf/0705.3844 for more details. Also, see Seung+Mugetalk)

Model file for CalcHEP implementation of RS radion (with radion mass larger than ~400 GeV) is linked in the following link (from Seung): http://www-pnp.physics.ox.ac.uk/~karagozm/workshops/leshouches09/radion_model.tgz . As of 24th june 09, these files can be downloaded and used.

With this model file, sigma(gg->R->WW) is about 0.1pb at 10 TeV and 0.3pb at 14TeV, for m_radion=500 GeV. This makes radion in various decay channels feasible at LHC. Corresponding cross section plot for r->WW by Muge is here.

(5). t', b' -> t/b + W/Z/H

The composite/KK partners of fermions have typically masses similar to W'/Z' and hence are constrained to be ~2 TeV (in turn, based on masses of W'/Z' required to satisfy precision tests). DIRECT constraints on masses of these fermions can be weaker. In this case, even single production of these fermionic partners might be very small (pair production is even smaller).

However, in certain (well-motivated) models the partners of top, bottom (in the generalized sense, i.e., including extended symmetries/representations for fermions) can be lighter than W'/Z', possibly ~500 GeV. Hence, production (both pair and single, perhaps in association with other SM particles) can be significant. The fermionic partners can decay into t/b + W/Z/H, with W/Z being boosted (even for fermionic partners being ~500 GeV). For example, for pair production of B' at 500 GeV, production sigma = ~ 1pb @10 TeV.

In addition, some models have "exotic" heavy/composite fermions, i.e., with electric charges 4/3 and 5/3.

(see references http://arXiv.org/pdf/hep-ph/0701158 and http://arXiv.org/pdf/0801.1679 for more details. Also, see Seung+Muge's talk.)

[A few comments are in order:

(a) It turns out that W/Z in all channels above are dominantly LONGITUDINAL. All the above decay patterns follow automatically from overlaps of profiles in extra dimension: light SM fermions are localized near the Planck brane and photon, gluon and transverse W/Z have flat profiles, whereas all KK's, Higgs (including longitudinal W/Z) and top quark are localized near the TeV brane. In the 4D picture, the light fermions are mostly elementary and Higgs and top are mostly composite, whereas photon, gluon and transverse W/Z are sort of in-between.

(b) As mentioned above, masses below 2 TeV for W'/Z' are strongly disfavored by lower-energy precision tests, whereas graviton' mass is expected to be of similar size to W'/Z' and hence is (in turn) also constrained to be above ~2 TeV. Radion mass can vary from ~100 GeV to ~2 TeV.

(c) Finally, one can lower the UV brane scale to below Planck scale, of course at the expense of not explaining the full Planck-weak hierarchy (but still explaining the flavor hierarchy). Such a modified framework - dubbed "little RS": see reference - leads to larger couplings to light fermions than the framework which explains the Planck-weak hierarchy, whereas couplings to top/W/Z/H are reduced. Hence, production cross-section for W'/Z' via q qbar annihilation is enhanced and so are the decays to cleaner channels such as dileptons.]


  • W,Z from Heavy neutrinos pair production from Z' in the U(1)_B-L model Basso LH09 talk

Heavy neutrino pair production: up to ~100fb, decaying in (see reference http://arxiv.org/pdf/0812.4313 for more details):

- WW+2leptons (up to ~25fb);

- WZ+1leptons + MET (up to ~25fb);

- ZZ+MET (up to ~6fb);

- WH+1leptons + MET (up to ~25fb);

- ZH+MET (up to ~12fb);

- HH+MET (up to ~6fb);

---

Outline:

Please put your input here, and sign up where you would volunteer to work. Some usual suspects are already listed.

(Note: depending on the details level, we still may have various options: we could turn each section into seperate write-ups or have each KK particle as a seperate write-up)

Summary of warped phenomenology in boosted final states

  • Introduction to phenomenology (Kaustubh/Christophe)
  • List of particles with suggested model parameters from current EWK constraints and yields at the LHC
    • bosons
      • radions (Rogerio/Christophe/Muge/Seung?)
      • KK gravitions (Shri?)
      • KK W/Z (?)
    • fermions (Muge?/?)
  • Comments on LHC prospects in various final states (James/Heather/Muge/?)
    • fully hadronic
    • semileptonic
    • fully leptonic
  • Summary (all)
Personal tools